American health blogger Cort Johnson looks at which ME/CFS treatment studies have been published since the start of 2013.
He highlights that there has been a lack of drug studies and that most of the these studies were small.
Extracts:
“With only one type of non-behavioral treatment, acupuncture, being assessed in more than one study, few of these treatment options have a chance of going mainstream. (CBT/GET studies showed up in 38 citations). The countries that dominated the behavioral studies (n=36) – the UK and the Netherlands – showed a distinct preference for the types of studies they wish to fund; they produced only three non-behavioral studies.”
“The implications of two governments [UK & Dutch] focusing substantial funding on one treatment type is clear: a dramatic restriction of the possible treatment options recommended for doctors and ultimately for most patients. Few of the treatments ME/CFS experts use showed up in this survey and few of which are available to patients seeing non-experts.
When a slim portion of the possible treatment options for a disease gets outsized attention three things happen: that treatment gets an undue focus in the media, doctors and patients treatment options are limited, and patients miss possibilities for treatment.”
One [factor] is the unwillingness of federal funders such as the NIH to fund research that will reveal viable treatment targets for drug manufacturers. This poor research funding has left ME/CFS a biological mystery. This has opened the door, as has happened so many times to so many diseases over time, to a behavioral interpretation of it.
The willingness of federal funders in the UK and Europe to pump large amounts of money into the behavioral treatment trials has effectively exploited that opening. A significant portion of the medical profession either accepts a behavioral interpretation of ME/CFS or has little or no knowledge of other possible treatments.
Treatment Survey
Behavioral = 53 citations
- CBT alone or CBT/GET -38 citations
- Graduated exercise therapy – 6
- Pacing — 3
- Yoga — 2
- Others – 8 • Multidisciplinary Study • Relaxation Therapy • Stress Management • Meditation – symptom management • Self-management • Guided Self Instruction • Symptom control • Emotional involvement significant others
Non-Behavioral = 25 citations
Drugs:
- Rituximab (29 people) – Norway
- Cytokine blocker (50 people) – Netherlands
- Clonidine (176) – Norway
- IVIG (1) – Italy
- Ondansetron (5)- Netherlands
- Valganciclovir (30) – US
- lisdexamfetamine dimesylate (26) – US
Supplements and Diet:
- GcMAF – Japan – case studies – 3 people
- B-12/Folic Acid – Sweden
- Diet – Review article – US
- COQ10 – Spain
- Herbal China review – China
- Vit D – UK
- Herb – Italy – II – french oak wood extract
- CoQ10 – Spain
- Traditional Chinese Medicine – Review – China
- Multivitamin – Serbia
- Acetaminophen – Belgium
Other and Alternative Health:
- Acupuncture – S Korea, China, S Korea
- Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy – Turkey
- Mercury removal – 1 person case study – Korea
- Other
Multidisciplinary Treatments – Italy
Countries of Origin:
US – 4 Italy – 3 Korea – 3 China – 3 Norway — 3 Netherlands – 2 Spain – 2 Belgium – 1 Turkey – 1 Serbia – 1 Sweden – 1 UK- 1
Read more: The Chokehold Behavioral Treatments Have on Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, by Cort Johnson, Nov 11, 2015